Oddly, one's physique isn't a very accurate measure of width requirement. For over two years I rode on a Romin 130mm Spesh saddle (as I'm pretty slim) and was not hugely impressed with it but couldn't justify changing it at the time. It's only when a LBS became a specialized dealer that I sat on the 'assometer' that measures the correct width to find that I was a 155mm width. The best thing is to get measured-it only takes a couple of minutes. The correct width was a revelation. I prefer the Toupe comp as it gives a bit more padding and the Pro is the super light race version which isn't me.