dirttorpedo
Senior Retro Guru
I'm responding to the thread title as I found the actual post too difficult to follow.
Personally I think it depends on the owners goals and the value of the bicycle / frame historically. I typically own a bunch of mediocre crap bikes so a sympathetic historic restoration does not make any sense. I also like the functionality of 8 speed and 9 speed drive trains and doing drop bar conversions to have a bias towards practical updates/upgrades. I find that retromods can look a bit out of place if done incorrectly and I'm not a big fan of owners welding disc brake tabs onto classic frames.
Personally I think it depends on the owners goals and the value of the bicycle / frame historically. I typically own a bunch of mediocre crap bikes so a sympathetic historic restoration does not make any sense. I also like the functionality of 8 speed and 9 speed drive trains and doing drop bar conversions to have a bias towards practical updates/upgrades. I find that retromods can look a bit out of place if done incorrectly and I'm not a big fan of owners welding disc brake tabs onto classic frames.