suburbanreuben":7n7u4y62 said::shock: It seems silly to risk buggering up a perfectly good frame for the sake of 50grammes though- I've always assumed the seatpost MUST extend below the top tube.
Anthony":a4q2dhfu said:I assume you have cut/machined the slot between the upper and lower bands, and I just thought I could see a line there (below)mikesnowdon":a4q2dhfu said:Machined angle?
perry":ig9q90rw said::shock:
please change to a longer post ; your putting a lot of faith in the top of the seattube taking all the strain . I wouldn't be surprised if it tears right off .
Change to a longer post and drill it .
Thanks for the offermikesnowdon":mpm7q703 said:suburbanreuben":mpm7q703 said::shock: It seems silly to risk buggering up a perfectly good frame for the sake of 50grammes though- I've always assumed the seatpost MUST extend below the top tube.
If the frame gets damaged in any way as a result I'll give you the whole bike ok![]()
Like I already said. There is the same amount of post in the frame as the recommended minimum by Thomson. And If kona thought it was an issue they would'nt have extended seat tubes. Chill winston!
You worry too much
EDIT: I take it back! You cant have the bike! (Im going to get a new post)
I think I'm right in saying that the post manufacturer's recommended minimum insert is concerned with the integrity of the post, not the frame. I think any frame manufacturer would recommend inserting below the welded area.mikesnowdon":m71las5h said:There is the same amount of post in the frame as the recommended minimum by Thomson. And If kona thought it was an issue they would'nt have extended seat tubes. Chill winston!
suburbanreuben":3q8fa4ir said:Thanks for the offermikesnowdon":3q8fa4ir said:suburbanreuben":3q8fa4ir said::shock: It seems silly to risk buggering up a perfectly good frame for the sake of 50grammes though- I've always assumed the seatpost MUST extend below the top tube.
If the frame gets damaged in any way as a result I'll give you the whole bike ok![]()
Like I already said. There is the same amount of post in the frame as the recommended minimum by Thomson. And If kona thought it was an issue they would'nt have extended seat tubes. Chill winston!
You worry too much
EDIT: I take it back! You cant have the bike! (Im going to get a new post), but if I want a frame knackered, I'll send it off to Bob the Bramley Butcher.
![]()
Do get yourself a longer post though- It WILL bend/snap the seat tube.