Scottish independence

[Andy R]

you will never understand what the Scotland/England relationship is because your not Scots. The Irish and Welsh would probably agree on this point.

And so would I

 

[Andy R]

A well written, thoughtful post - and one expressing views that I'm in complete agreement with.

 

[technodup]

Pushing for independence and for further powers is all to do with running Scotland according to the principles the majority of the population adhere to,

I'm confident the referendum will show that to be untrue.

And if devo max was to be an option so should disbanding Holyrood be. That's the only way I'd get a proper vote. Otherwise we're just delaying the supposedly inevitable. The best thing that can come out of this is Salmond and Sturgeon to be roundly defeated and for it to be put on the back burner for a generation. At least until I'm too old to care.

Most Scots couldn't name an MSP if they had a week to think about it. I'd be surprised if more than 25% could even name their own. Sturgeon is mine- other than her and Salmond I'd have to go back to Dewar, McConnell, Sheridan or Canavan to think of anyone of any substance. So why would people who don't follow politics vote to hand complete control over to a rag tag bunch of ex teachers and social workers? A Mel Gibson film and a shit football team? Gies a brek.

Sooner this shite is over with the better imo.

 

[dyna-ti]

Im enjoying the horror story propaganda being released by the English government and their buddies in the media.

 

[Mr Panda]

Perhaps one of the amusing factors is that a very significant body of support for the SNP et al lies with English incomers. Free health care for the elderly and schooling for kids. Apparently, LOL

I'm Glaswegian, lived in London and the home counties aged 22 - 39, then moved back north because I chose to. No significant arguments for voting "Yes" have yet been presented to me, and I suspect they won't.

As for Farage, I wouldn't pee on him if he was on fire.

 

[technodup]

I strongly disagree that most Scots are as ignorant as you suggest. I reckon the people who don't know their MSPs would be unlikely to know their MPs or MEPs. Nothing to do with the Scottish Government, just ignorance.

So they're not ignorant because they don't know MSPs but are ignorant because they don't know MPs? I'm confused.

And it's not a government btw. It's the Scottish Executive in the Scotland Act and no amount of rebranding by Salmond is changing it. Governments do stuff like collect taxes rather than just spend grants from actual proper countries like the UK.

Scotland has long been socialist, and after New Labour and their Scottish counterparts the SNP were the only option if you were a Scotland resident wanting true socialism.

Not disagreeing there. But it just demonstrates more ignorance.

If Scotland had proper socialism I think we'd want out of it pretty sharply. Who's going to pay for it when we don't have London generating the wealth? I wouldn't want to bet my house on a few poxy windmills.

 

[technodup]

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-22555659
78% of people couldn't name their MP. That's most to me. And although it's not Scotland specific I can't see why that result would be reversed up here.

I didn't say London creates all the wealth, it's fairly obvious it doesn't. But it does have a GDP per capita twice that of Scotland. To think a wee town like Edinburgh is suddenly going to compete is wishful thinking.

 

[Rumble]

Ah, the wonderful Alex Salmond stoking the flames to feed his own notoriety. After all, he's the only man in the world who seems not to understand the conventions that govern national borders and territorial waters when licking his lips over 'Scottish' oil.

I say we let Scotland have It's independence. The rest of the UK can stop funding them at a level grossly disproportionate to their GDP, the Welsh can have the nuclear subs and the jobs that go with them, and Scotland can rely on men with blue painted faces who strangle cats for music to defend them, or to perhaps act as a tourist attraction.

At the risk of feeding the troll... what an excellent demonstration of exactly why I'll be voting for independence.

 

[KDM]

Sorry to pop this up again but an article in the Times the day before yesterday made me think some would appreciate it.

For a long time people like Mr Salmon have basically inferred Scotland wished it's independence and can largely be fund it through North Sea Oil and of course still taking money off the rest off the U.K. whilst claiming to be independent.

Recently the Island collective including the Shetlands, Western Isles, Orkneys etc have said that should the independence go through then they would seek the same independence from Scotland that the Falkland Islands have from the U.K. and they the islands collective, would now control the oil and it's revenues as it is in their waters. That's a poke in the eye for Mr Salmon and rather would leave him in a difficult situation.

 

[velomaniac]

Would England really let us Scots have the revenue from North Sea oil if we we became independent, really ?

Aye Right ! as we say up here.

What are we going to do about it since more people live in London than live in the entirety of scotland, settle it over a punch up, get real.

Scotland will be poor if we dont remain in UK or EU, we'll just be Ireland with most of our talent emigrated.

There is no fire in the Scots belly beyond an irational hatred of the English based on wars fought in past history. Whole referendum is another waste of taxpayers money.

More should be done to make the United Kingdom a united kingdom so that we all think of ourselves as equal citizens of the same place, not the north/south, them/us attitude that has been the norm in this land for far too long.

Edit:- Previous statements by myself on this matter may have suggested I'm pro independence. However the SNP's case for independence has no substance, it all says everything will be ticketyboo just because and thats basically it.
Pathetic :facepalm: