Dog Man Star by Suede (only problem being, it's on double vinyl, and it's hard to get fully chilled out when I have to get up and change it three times)
If You're Feeling Sinister - Belle & Sebastian
Peloton - Delgados
Psyence Fiction - UNKLE
Push The Button - Money Mark
Also, any early REM is ftw - I remember having the eponymous compilation on tape when I was younger, and nearly wore it out.
All the above are on vinyl. I think with cds, it's so much easier to just skip the tracks you're less fond of, and in the end you're only ever listening to 2 or 3 tracks from each album. I've also tried replacing worn-out records with cd/mp3 copies, and they just never quite sound as good, even though they're 10 times cleaner.