yes in my opinion, it destroys the spirit of these types of sites and trust in members, I also play with old land rovers and a similar mindset exists on the landy forums particularly where difficult to find parts are concerned and passed on to help with a rebuild, where the expectation is that items are not to be passed on to be sold. The one caveat would be if there was some honesty about intentions in advance or obviously a trader which sounds like is not the case in this instance, are you going to name and shame ?