rBOTM March - Vote now !

The poll --->>

  • Bastos' Koga

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Adam's Vitus

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Johntomjoe's Peugeot

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Slotcar's Picchio Special

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kevin's Galetti

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Retroian's Cannondale

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Rowley's Peugeot

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Nick's Daccordi

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Flipster's Swinnerton

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
  • Poll closed .

Elev12k

Moderator
BoTM Winner
Gold Trader
rBotM Winner
Feedback
View
You can vote now :D

Bastos' Koga >>>

6806569524_9eae64202c_c.jpg


Adam's Vitus >>>

v3.jpg


Johntomjoe's Peugeot >>>

imag0191_149.jpg


Slotcar's Picchio Special >>>

img_0447_815.jpg


Kevin's Galetti >>>

Galletti100.jpg


Retroian's Cannondale >>>

imgp1050_252.jpg


Rowley's Peugeot >>>

6985629273_0bccef9837_b.jpg


Nick's Daccordi >>>

daccordi_retrobike_shot_resize_929.jpg


Flipster's Swinnerton >>>

Swinnerton008.jpg
 

yo-Nate-y

Senior Retro Guru
Feedback
View
TOUGH choice!

1st place is about three bikes for me.
a very close 2nd is another two .... great selection this month!
 

wired99

Retrobike Rider
Feedback
View
I like the Picchio and Daccordi frames the best but have small gripes with both. Would have loved to see the Picchio draped in Campag and I really would have preferred a more period correct saddle on the Daccordi. Nit picking taken to a new level I guess but there you go.

So, my vote goes to the Koga, just lovely.
 

Goldie

Senior Retro Guru
Spoiled for choice this month - I love the Daccordi, Rowley's fresh-out-of-the-box Peugeot, Bastos's spotless Koga and that gorgeous Swinnerton. But couldn't resist the Galetti.
 

Jamiedyer

Moderator
Gold Trader
MacRetro Rider
Feedback
View
Vitus

Yes, really spoiled for choice this month, some really outstanding machines. All very nice, but the Vitus did it for me, just looks 'fit for purpose' it really just came down to aesthetics.
I was the first one to vote so Adam at one piont you had 100% of the vote ;)

Jamie
 

Citoyen du monde

rBotM Winner
In a month like this where there are many interesting bikes, I always delve into what makes each of the the bikes special and unique, as well as important from a historical point of view.

This means that the bikes that are largely machine built like the Koga Miyata (the robotized production plant was a sight to see back in the day, but doesn't give you a warm and fuzzy feeling of getting the product of a craftsman), Vitus (I don't find see much craftsmanship in gluing) and Blue Peugeot and Cannondale (semi-automated assembly line production) get excluded.

This leaves 5 bikes that are largely hand-crafted, namely the Picchio, Galetti, Peugeot Perthus, Daccordi and Swinnerton, with the Peugeot and Daccordi showing the least signs of manual labour being used (they were likely being built on a carrousel).

Of the Picchio, Galetti and Swinnerton it is clear that the Picchio and Galetti show the greatest craftsmanship. If you have ever seen raw lugs and BB shell from the 40's you will understand how much manual labour has gone into the Galetti, just like all the special tubing shaping done on the Picchio. In comparison the Swinnerton, no matter how attractive it might be simply can hold a candle in the workmanship stakes. So my choice was winnowed down to either the Picchio or Galetti. Both are evocative of their time, which in both cases was a time of great change. Within 5 years of the building of the Galetti the whole bike landscape which had followed a evolutionary path up until then underwent a game-changing modification that immediately made many bikes obsolete (the cambio corsa equipped bike disappeared from the race scene at all levels within two years after having been considered one of the best bikes for over a decade!). As for the Picchio, this was one of the last of what I still consider to be the classic age which ran from the 50's to the late 80's (quill stem, steel frame, non-indexed shifting, no brifters, toe clips...), before getting into the modern age which more or less runs from the 90's to today.

The Picchio and Galetti are therefore both prime examples of great workmanship and of historical importance (documenting the end of an era). My vote for the RBotM went to the Picchio because it is the most period correct, but I would like to suggest that we institute a new RBRotM (Retro bike Rider of the Month) that I think should go to Kevin for his Galetti.
 

roadking

Senior Retro Guru
Galetti for me, am in broad agreement with Cdm.

For me it encapsulates what might be regarded as the golden age.

Roadking.
 

daccordimark

Senior Retro Guru
Feedback
View
The Galetti got my vote for all the reasons everyone has already mentioned. I surprised myself by liking an older machine as I normally go for 1980s as that was my "golden age".

The Swinnerton was a close second.

Mark.
 
Top