Carbon or Titanium... the impossible choice.

Neil G · Jun 27, 2012

Obviously not that many people buying them then, maybe they're worried about low end carbon letting go?

Dickyboy · Jun 27, 2012

For cosmetic longevity it has to be Ti surely? Can only imagine what a carbon MTB frame would look like after 5 or more years use.

To be honest if I was buying again now, I'd more than likely go for decent steel instead of Ti or Carbon.

Takingabreak · Jun 27, 2012

Carbon bike frame? Scary.

Ok for mudguards and car dashboard trim I guess, but sit on it and ride it when gravity has got the better of me?

Besides, you can't even decorate it with fridge magnets

Neil G · Jun 28, 2012

Dickyboy":2in1t83x said:
For cosmetic longevity it has to be Ti surely? Can only imagine what a carbon MTB frame would look like after 5 or more years use.

To be honest if I was buying again now, I'd more than likely go for decent steel instead of Ti or Carbon.

+1

I think a high end steel frame has got to be better than a low rent carbon frame.

Ti is amazing stuff, keeps it's looks over the years no matter how much abuse. My 93 Hei Hei proved that, still looks new even after all this time!

ibbz · Jan 3, 2023

Interesting thread
I’m wondered whether things have changed in 11 years since this discussion ?

Takingabreak · Jan 3, 2023

ibbz said:
Interesting thread
I’m wondered whether things have changed in 11 years since this discussion ?

Still scary. The carbon forks on my ti road bike are always raising the “will they fail today” question in my head

MattiThundrrr · Jan 5, 2023

On a ti bike, this would be a little scratch. Would you trust this carbon frame?

ibbz · Jan 5, 2023

MattiThundrrr said:
On a ti bike, this would be a little scratch. Would you trust this carbon frame?View attachment 692536

Oooh nooooooo!!!!!

How will these über expensive frames fare as Retrobikes in 15 years time
I always wondered why RB 98 section has hardly any UCI WTB World Cup winning carbon bikes from the 00ies and 10’s and more recent - probably all wrecked

coomber · Jan 6, 2023

I think most carbon bikes, especially hardtails look really ugly. Give me straight tubes every day of the week.

Other opinions will vary

ibbz · Jan 8, 2023

coomber said:
I think most carbon bikes, especially hardtails look really ugly. Give me straight tubes every day of the week.

Other opinions will vary

Tend to agree

Carbon or Titanium... the impossible choice.

Neil G

Old School Grand Master

Dickyboy

Senior Retro Guru

Takingabreak

Neil G

Old School Grand Master

ibbz

Takingabreak

MattiThundrrr

ibbz

coomber

ibbz

Similar threads

Latest posts