What kind of riding are they for ?
Just thinking that if its offroad where you need to operate controls and brakes quite a lot then fingered gloves are pretty much a given,though you'll always have the problem of them being warm too bulky to operate the controls easily
If its general faffing about commuting etc then have you considered lobster claws ? Its a 2 fingered glove so you keep fingers together and therefore warmer than standard 4 fingered gloved without the same bulk.
In the 90's Specialized sold a lobster claw glove made of neoprene,not waterproof though it did take a bit of time[for the water to soak through] but that didnt matter because they were so bloody warm.
I might still have them around though theyre likely to be tatty as hell as i was using them sailing for a few years.
Took a google look and found a good link for winter glove recommendations.The Spesh ones are featured in it an rate 8/10
http://www.stirlingbikeclub.org.uk/club ... ndex.shtml
Added bonus- You can pretend to be a Penguin
1976 Raleigh Chipper,1991 Muddy Fox Adventurer, 1992 Raleigh Diablo ,1992 Rudy Project, 1995 Cannondale M200 ,1997 Santa Cruz Tazmon ,1997 Specialized Stumpjumper ,1997 Specialized Rockhopper ,1997 Marin Quake 9.0,1998 Marin Pallisade trail ,1998 Raleigh Torus,1999 Orange Clockwork , 2005 Kona Hahanna , 2010 Orange Pure7
The Marvellous Mechanical Hope Collection