All of the waterproof ones I've tried I've found annoying.
I always find that the inner liner pulls out with my fingers, and then is a pain to get everything back in.
If it's just cold, I bought some really thin silk gloves and wear them under a thicker pair.
Works for me
Yeah, their sizes are a bit ropey too. I got M/L for my M/L sized hands, but they are a bit on the tight side. I'm going to get another pair when they have more in stock but will be going for XL.
It's not been truly cold yet, but no complaints so far. And when the wife inevitably calls me on a lunchtime mudfest, I don't have to struggle to answer the phone.