It needn't be as tight as a fixie, after all you don't have the same danger if the chain unships. I work on something being able to deflect around 15mm from the straight line with finger pressure.
In other words, you should see some slight sag on the bottom of the chain when the bike is parked
cheers Ham, based on what you're saying I think I've gone from too slack to too tight now
PARTS FOR SALE:
vintage Brooks Professional saddle | Specialized FACT CX fork | Columbus fork | Reynolds 531 fork | Avid Arch Rival v-brakes | various 700c, 27" and 26" wheels | vintage Weco hubs (fixed/freewheel) | vintage Raleigh ladies frames + lots more!