I don't know... My Clockwork did very well and it is a fairly lowly model. Also Amybrook's LavaDome has a story attached which we can all relate too. It may not be the bike which is the best or the oldest but it does kind of sum up the spirit of "retrobike".
All due respect to the other guy's though, I'd love to see the Boulder win, the Merlin is awesome just on rarity alone and the Salsa is a true survivor and a supercool bike too! I voted for the Miyata road bike beacuse I vote for the bike I'd most like to take home each month. That road bike is a doll!
Somerset, like 'Heartbeat' with newer cars!
Retro MTB: 1992 Cannondale M1000 Deore XT M730. 1992 Raleigh Dyna Tech Quantum Deore XT.
Retro Road: 1992 Eddy Merckx Corsa Extra Telekom Shimano 600 STI. 1993 Dyna Tech Ti Campagnolo Athena 8 Ergopower.
Modern: 2004 Wilier scandium Ultegra 6600. 2014 Wilier GTR Ultegra 6800.